WinterSpray's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Jerry Jackalope - The Fishing Trip]

Congrats on getting third place, fellas!

Alright, so here's my thoughts. First of all, the writing is kinda sloppy. It's like, I could identify where a joke was, but I didn't really find them all that funny. In situations like that it's a good practice to identify what you find funny and use that style of humor in your writing. I personally like absurdist, meta-style humor, so I try to find ways to put that in my scripts. Try applying that practice in your scripts in the future. But to be fair, I could've just not found them funny because they didn't appeal to my sense of humor. It's totally possible that y'all got the whole squad laffin and I'm the weird one in this instance.

Secondly, it's very jarring to go from very smooth animation to janky, 2003-style flash animation, to decently cromulent, eddsworld-quality animation. It's kinda hard to watch because nothing seems to be done to hide it. It just goes from one skill level of animation to another. I don't really know how this can be improved other than building a more skilled creative team or taking the time to improve the skills of the one you already have. Animation takes time, yes, but you have to think about how your product is being presented and how it can be the highest quality it can be. I look back on my animated short films, ones I spent years to animate, and hate them because I can see where I could've done better.

On something a little more positive, the audio editing was done very well as well as the choice of music. I wouldn't be surprised if you just ripped that track from a ren and stimpy episode. It's very well done and probably my favorite part.
The art style is pretty nice as well, I got no gripes with it.

Take this criticism with a grain of salt. I don't really animate anymore and I've never gotten a daily third place or anything like that. Seriously though, keep working on this. I think y'all got something good going here.

Smith-Toons responds:

Thanks for the critique! I can agree on some points lol. But thanks for watching aswell!!

[Newgrounds DS Collab]

this is cool, but I think it'd be better if the title was NewgrounDS collab, so it matches with the title seen in the animation, er, game... whatever this is

DannyGoodShirt responds:

It's the Groundnew SD Collab erm... thanks for watching erm

[Banned Pastry Commercial]

aint no party like a diddy party

[Interview with Mothra]

mothra is a giant chicken confirmed

[FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY’S COLLAB]

Shoutout to NevaZ0r for making us do their job for them. Nah, honestly tho everyone did a great job here. And even tho they dropped off the face of the earth, Neva is the guy who brought us all here and made this possible in the first place.

EDIT: Some people are saying that the "original" collab is still happening. I'm not gonna deny that cause I'm just an animator with no connections to the organizer or "team" behind this collab, but nobody told us this. Another guy said that the collab was pushed back to give some people time to do their animations, which might be possible. I have no idea if it is or not nor do I have the authority to say it isn't. But if it is, everyone really could've benefited from someone coming to the forum and saying that, which no one did. I checked. If this was something said on the discord server I wouldn't know that either because I'm not in it.

The point is we were left totally in the dark and we decided to just do it. If someone had told us, or replied to our emails, we wouldn't feel the need to do this ourselves. Maybe a big chunk of people were more active on the server and the team didn't feel the need to answer emails or forum posts because "oh hey everyone's in here. why would we do that?". But communication is communication, no matter where it's posted, when it's posted, or if nobody's reading it. And I think everyone involved would say the same if someone asked them.

If the team still wants to do the original collab, or add onto this already existing one, contact JAM-POWER. Again, I'm just an animator. I have no ties to the creation of this collab other than my animation.

[mmm... beeEEeeRrrr]

me when the perc 30 hits

[sonic's alone time]

i cant believe this wasn't in sonic shorts 9

[Fantasy Factory]

actually seems like a pretty cool game concept. i think this might play pretty well in an episode of TADC after it's been tweaked a little bit.

[VIBINVENDETTA [the appetizer] RELEASE TRAILER]

it looks fun. i'm excited to see where this goes!

also just an idea: i think in future updates y'all should add in other characters from the NG community to make it resonate with peeps more. don't lean too heavily into it because then you might just have a "love letter to newgrounds = game with pico in it" situation which we see constantly already, but get in some smaller animators and devs to have their characters in it or design original characters for the game. or you could do like a lottery to see which of their own characters gets in? idk i just think that would be neat.

beenibroh responds:

i see what you mean! but the game is supposed to be a tribute to a friend group we've known for years

[Joel finds Maxwell]

its perfect